21 minutes 27 seconds
Rebecca Choo Quan: Imagine you have spent decades saving for retirement and the big day has finally come, but the paychecks have stopped, and the hard part begins: turning your wealth into income. Welcome to season three of Better Vantage by Vanguard, a podcast series hosted by Custom Content from WSJ and Vanguard. I’m Rebecca Choo Quan of Vanguard’s Investment Strategy Group sitting in today for Christine Kashkari of WSJ Custom Content. And with me is co-host and our resident expert, Joe Davis, global chief economist at Vanguard. Joe, in season one, we asked, “Is America even ready to retire?” But today we’re going to ask, “How do we actually do it?” Joining us to help answer that question are Kelly Hahn, Vanguard’s head of retirement research, and Garrett Harbron, Vanguard’s head of advised wealth management strategies. Kelly, Garrett, thanks so much for spending time with us today.
Garrett Harbron: Thanks, Rebecca. Good to be here.
Kelly Hahn: Thanks for having us.
Joe Davis: As my mom likes to remind me, I’m no spring chicken, right? So, retirement income is increasingly important. It’s important to my parents as well. And there’s times it’s like I don’t know where to go, what information to trust. And I’m greedy here for our listeners, like I want actionable items, right? And so I think what I’m really excited—Kelly and Garrett, giving their expertise. They’re going to turn that conceptual idea into reality for us.
Rebecca: Yeah, you need to get your advice right here and right now. So, we are going to start with a little bit of a lightning round and just ask a few quick-fire questions that we will then dig into later in the podcast. So, why don’t we start with the first one? There’s this so-called 4% rule. Is that useful or outdated? Garrett?
Garrett: Surprisingly, useful.
Joe: Really, how about so how about annuities? Good, bad, indifferent?
Garrett: It depends.
Kelly: It depends.
Joe: Oh man, you sound like an economist here. It depends…
Kelly: Retirement income is such a hard problem to solve. How many years have people been retiring, and we’re still dealing with this challenge because it’s so complicated?
Rebecca: We promise not to just say it depends. We’ll get some accurate answers. What’s the biggest retirement myth you’d like to eliminate?
Kelly: Well, RMD isn’t the only thing you can withdraw from.
Rebecca: RMD—required minimum distributions. Garrett?
Garrett: Your account balance is not what determines whether you retire successfully.
Joe: All right. Whoa. I shouldn’t be looking at my account balance? Not the most important thing?
Garrett: Not the most important thing.
Joe: All right, we’re going to come back to that.
Garrett: Absolutely.
Rebecca: Biggest misconception retirees have about spending in retirement?
Garrett: It’s easy.
Rebecca: I find spending to be very easy.
Kelly: That they don’t want to spend because of all of the worries and anxiety they have about uncertainties. I mean, that’s certainly the case with my mom. She’s a widow, and I think her biggest worry is that she’s going to be a burden to her kids, me and my sisters. So, she’s very, very frugal and intentionally so. So, what we’re trying to work with her is you do have some capacity to spend and how do we get you more comfortable utilizing the wealth. So, I feel like a lot of people feel they can’t spend their money.
Rebecca: What’s one thing a new retiree should do on their very first day of retirement?
Kelly: Consolidate accounts.
Garrett: Decide what you want your retirement to look like.
Joe: All right, all right, so there’s a lot to unpack here, right? A lot to unpack here. Where do you want to go? We want to go to the mindset shift.
Rebecca: Let’s talk about that. I mean, interestingly, so Kelly as head of retirement research, looks at millions of participant accounts in 401(k) plans and millions of investors in America in their 401(k) plans. So, it’s sort of the average Joe account, not your account, Joe. So, maybe she can tell us a little bit about how the average American worker is thinking about retirement income.
Kelly: So, I want to ask you a question. Since we’re being interviewed, I’m going to flip the tables. How many people in America, the average Americans, are doing what economists think they should do? Smooth consumption into retirement. It’s not a trick question, Joe. What do you think?
Joe: Can I say it depends? No, 40%.
Kelly: Forty percent. No, that is a high number. Only 1 in 10 average Americans in retirement are consistently taking money out from their wealth. And for the most part, the vast majority, they’re hoarding or holding on to their wealth because of all the anxieties and worries they have about what retirement may look like.
Joe: Can you say that again? Just 1 in 10?
Kelly: One in ten. Yeah, 1 in 10. About half, they’re tapping their retirement wealth when they need it, like a piggy bank. Where about 40%, they’re not taking any money out until they get to RMD age, which is really shocking when you think about it. It could be 10 years of not spending money. People are intentionally being frugal, just like my mom. It gives her joy of knowing that she’s saving up her wealth in case something happens. Long-term care or health care.
Rebecca: Peace of mind. That’s got a value.
Garrett: Peace of mind absolutely has value, right? And, and I think that’s one of the important things to keep in mind when we’re talking about retirement spending. One of the reasons we say a lot that it depends is because we can do the math. We can tell people, like from a quantitative standpoint, here is what the ideal is. But I haven’t come across an algorithm or a formula yet that captures peace of mind. And I think we have to really remember that peace of mind has its value. We may not be able to calculate it, but that doesn’t mean that someone who trades optimal tax strategy for a little bit more peace of mind is making a bad decision.
Kelly: It’s really the balance of how much you can generate today versus how much you may need in the future for peace of mind. So I think retirees really need to think about both. But right now, it’s very much overweight to what’s going to happen to me. I don’t want to spend the money in case something major or something dire may happen.
Joe: You mentioned Social Security. You mentioned RMD. Like, that’s where I need help here. How do I start breaking through?
Garrett: Yeah, I think that is where creating a retirement plan, a spending plan, really has a lot of value. So, people need to ask themselves, “What do I want my retirement to look like? What do I want to do? What hobbies do I want to engage in? What kind of travel might I want to do?” And create a budget for it and compare that budget to their assets and their spending plan to see if it’s sustainable.
And if you can do that, then that accomplishes a number of things. It helps you spend. It almost gives you permission to spend, in a way, because you’ve planned for it. It gives you the peace of mind that, yes, this spending plan is sustainable, and perhaps most importantly, it gives you the permission to live the retirement that you want to live.
Rebecca: So, Kelly, you have actually done a lot of research about one of the biggest misconceptions people have—RMDs. Tell us what RMD is and what are people misthinking about them.
Kelly: RMD stands for required minimum distribution. It literally means it’s the minimum amount that you need to take out from your tax deferred portfolios like 401(k)s and IRAs. And many people think that they need to start taking out money when RMD starts, which can be 73 or 75 depending on their birth year. But when, in fact, people can actually start taking out money sooner as early as 59-1/2. And they also think it’s a recommendation by the government that how much they can safely draw down. It’s really not. It’s a way to tax the money that has not been taxed yet. So, what we recommend is that RMD should always be the floor. It’s part of the retirement income planning. But that should not be the only strategy.
Joe: Is that a big one?
Kelly: That’s a big one. That’s a really big one. About 4 in 10 are taking Social Security right as they retire, let’s say 63 or 64, and then they wait another full decade to take money out when RMD starts. But the tricky part with RMD is because you’re backloading everything, people may actually pay more in taxes in aggregate, lifetime taxes, that potentially a retiree may be paying, by delaying consumption.*
Joe: So you’ve underspent and then you paid more in taxes.
Kelly: Exactly.
Joe: How is this not more well known?
Kelly: This is why we’re doing the podcast!
Garrett: Just to add on to what Kelly was saying, you know, waiting to take RMDs for a lot of people is about the worst thing you can do from a tax standpoint, right? Because once you get into that RMD phase, you are forced to take money out year after year after year. It’s a required minimum distribution, right? And so, no matter what the rest of your tax picture looks like, once you start taking those RMDs, it can change that tax picture significantly, right? So, one of the big things that people run into is Social Security is taxable depending on what your other income looks like. So, it can be 0%, 50% or 85% taxable. Someone who is not used to having their Social Security taxed because they have relatively low income, probably because they haven’t been taking money from their retirement accounts, can suddenly find their Social Security is being taxed at that 85%.
Kelly: And Medicare surcharge.
Garrett: And Medicare surcharge. Exactly.
Rebecca: Okay, Garrett, let’s go back to something we talked about in the lightning round—the 4% rule. Is that now passe?
Garrett: No, it’s not passe at all. But let’s talk about what the 4% rule is and isn’t. The 4% rule says that in your first year of retirement, you spend 4% of your beginning account balance and then you spend that amount in dollars adjusted for inflation each year after that. Now a lot of people think that the 4% rule means you take 4% of your portfolio balance each year in retirement, and that’s not what this is.
Rebecca: That’s what I thought it was.
Joe: That’s a big difference.
Garrett: That’s a different rule. That’s the percentage of portfolio rule.
Kelly: So, I have very mixed feelings about the 4% rule. You know, I think giving people general guidance is a good thing because right now, as we see in the data itself, people are not utilizing their wealth. And we hear from our clients over and over, I don’t need any more educational materials, don’t teach me, just tell me what I should do. Right? So, I think 4% rule, something that they can follow easily is a good one. So, they can actually act on it. But because of the sequence of withdrawal, I find it difficult to recommend something that’s going to be static if you don’t come back and update your financial planning when things like market downturn may happen.
Garrett: Well, so you said two really important things there, right?
Kelly: I think I said many more.
Garrett: Fair. Two things that I’m going to reply to. One of the things that our research has found is that just a little bit of flexibility with your spending from year to year based on market returns can dramatically increase the lifetime of a portfolio.
Joe: So, take like a three-year moving average or something like that to smooth out the ups and downs of the stock market…
Garrett: Or just put a put a ceiling and floor above and below your spending.
Kelly: Like a guardrail.
Garrett: If you do what we call dynamic spending, which is you go into your spending plan saying, okay, I’m going to adjust my spending with market returns, but I’m not going to increase my budget by any more than 5% a year and I’m not going to decrease my budget by any more than 2-1/2% per year. That approach gets you a lot of the portfolio longevity benefits of a percentage of portfolio rule without all of the volatility.
Rebecca: But how do you deal with unexpected shocks? I mean, in retirement, you have could have a big, most often, health care shock. So, you might have the best laid plans for a floor and a ceiling and then something big happens and you need in-home care that’s not covered by Medicare or something like that.
Kelly: That’s why I think it’s really important at the outset to think about your goals in two buckets. What could I afford today knowing that there’s likelihood that I may have adverse health events? So, the number that you may use to generate income today may be somewhat lower in order to have the liquidity that you may need.
Joe: So, you would put that on the spreadsheet—$100,000 or some number for long-term care.
Kelly: You carve that out so that you have both peace of mind, if something happens, and then today being able to have that permission to spend and enjoy retirement.
Joe: My wife and I just did this with long-term care. We don’t know actually what number that’s going to be, but psychologically, I know once since the economist in me saying I’m just doing mental accounting, I just bucketed it. But, Kelly, I’m trying to channel you and Garrett, I’m saying that actually gave us, we just did this, it gave us a lot of comfort knowing that we don’t know if we’ll ever need it or someone in our family will need it, but we have dedicated funds that are just there for that, right? I actually labeled it on my Vanguard account, long-term care account.
Kelly: And surprisingly, a lot of people are going to need long-term care about 1 in 2. I mean, the severity may vary. And I think women are more likely, if we’re lucky, that we’re going to have a longer longevity, and health care and long-term care issues.
Joe: What’s a framework to help me get at some loose number for that sort of called sidecar for long-term care.
Garrett: So, coming up with an exact number is difficult. Because there are a lot of variables going into it. Where you live, your family history, these are all things that play into this number. That varies widely depending on where people live, the cost of long-term care varies greatly across different parts of the country. But probably the biggest indicator of what your long-term care costs are, or your spouse’s long-term care costs are going to be, is looking back at your parents and your grandparents and seeing what kind of long-term care they required and how long they lived.
Rebecca: It’s expensive so it’s really something you need to put a lot of thought up front into.
Joe: What’s your thoughts on annuities? And you sounded like an economist and saying: it depends.
Garrett: I’m going to go back to it depends, Joe.
Joe: Help break that down for me. Who is the strongest use case for it and what type of annuity, if you can go that far, where it’s viable knowing that it’s not for all.
Garrett: Annuities are best used when there is a gap between what we call essential expenses, right? Housing, food, utilities—the things that you can’t cut back on. And you’re guaranteed income. So, when we talk about guaranteed income, we’re talking about Social Security, pensions, that sort of thing. When that gap exists and there is real longevity risk involved, right? So, if you look at your account balance and your spending needs and you say, you know what, I only need to withdraw 2% of my portfolio per year, you really don’t have any meaningful longevity risk, right? But if you have what meaningful longevity risk and you have that gap between essential expenses and you’re guaranteed income, that’s where annuities become extremely valuable because annuities can plug that gap and give you guaranteed income that you can’t outlive and is not dependent on what the market does. And that’s exactly what you want when it comes to covering those essential expenses. You’re turning assets into income. That’s all you’re doing, right? You’re giving the insurance company assets and in return, they’re giving you a stream of income for the rest of your life.
Joe: Usually it’s like a percentage of the portfolio.
Garrett: Yeah, usually just a piece of it.
Kelly: Also, the biggest annuity that everybody has is Social Security.
Joe: Supplemental Social Security. Now what’s the retirement income 201 version, the more advanced version? What’s the next layer of potential help.
Rebecca: Or maybe even things coming over the next decade.
Garrett: So, I think one of the biggest things is tax planning, right? It’s one thing to figure out what your retirement plan is and what your spending plan is, but taxes can make a big difference over a period of 30 years. Like even small differences, you know, we talk a lot about the power of compounding of interest and things like that. We tend to forget that applies in retirement too. I think one of the biggest things people overlook are Roth conversions. We talk about them a lot, but I don’t know that they actually get done nearly as often as they should be.
Rebecca: Can you just explain what happens in a Roth conversion?
Garrett: So, Roth conversion, you’ve got your traditional 401(k), your traditional IRA, the money that you take out of that, it goes in tax free, but the money you take out gets taxed fully as income when you take it out, right? Not only that, but when you pass it on to your heirs, they have to pay income tax when they draw down on it as well. Roth IRA, you pay tax on the money that goes in, but neither you nor your heirs ever pay income tax on the withdrawals.
Another difference between a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA is Roth IRAs do not have any RMDs. So, there’s never a minimum drawdown that you have to take out of that account. So, what a Roth conversion does is you take money out of your traditional IRA or 401(k), pay the income tax on it, put it into a Roth vehicle IRA. And incidentally this has to be done directly. You can’t withdraw it and then redeposit it, right. And then that money from that point on grows tax free. Retirement, especially the early years of retirement, are a really good time to do that because you’re not working anymore. So, you’re out of the highest income years of your life, right? You may or may not be collecting Social Security at that point, depending on whether you’ve decided to delay claiming or not. But because of that, they tend to be some of the lowest income years in retirement and since they are low income, that means lower income tax. So, that is an ideal time to do Roth conversions and the tax savings from a Roth conversion, especially done early, can be really, really powerful depending on balances and things like that. We’ve seen real cases in our advice offer where clients saved a quarter of a million dollars in income taxes over their lifetime by doing a Roth conversion.
Joe: So, it sounds like the first day I retire, I’m doing a Roth conversion…
Garrett: Yeah, make sure you talk to someone like an advisor or an accountant, someone who knows what they’re doing, right? Because every dollar you don’t pay in tax is another dollar you have to spend and to give to family to give to causes you care about.
Kelly: So, I think for me, like one thing, if you were asking me where is 2.0 for retirement income would be—just like we’ve automated savings for people, I would love to automate generating income so we could give people permission to spend and safety.
Rebecca: So, automation might actually help you both get over the mindset and also control some of the risks.
Joe: So, how does every listener here, what is the one thing when they turn off this episode that they say you want to help their loved ones, to help themselves, if you haven’t done it already?
Kelly: People need to take stock of their situation. As I mentioned before, consolidation of accounts is so critical. People retire with three or four different accounts, 401(k)s, and IRAs. When you have things scattered all over, you don’t know how much you can generate. So, I mean, you ask for one thing, but I’m going to give you two or three things. Social Security, know how much you’re going to get. Make sure your balance sheet is consolidated so you have a holistic view. And then think about the life you want and can you afford it. I think those three things, people will get 90% of what they need to do, they can tackle that.
Garrett: I think the biggest single thing that people can do is really sit down and think about what is this money for. And that’s why I think a retirement plan is so important because it can bring that clarity and almost give permission for people to spend knowing that (a) they’ve identified all of their goals and (b) those goals are appropriately funded.
Rebecca: Yeah, I think that’s actually a great place to leave the conversation. I hope we all retire with more confidence.
Joe: It sounds like this is just going to be topic we could keep coming back to. Thank you Garrett, Kelly, amazing insights, gave us some action items, too. A lot to do. Thank you.
Rebecca: Date night with spreadsheets. Well, thank you so much, Kelly and Garrett. It’s been great to have you here. And that’s it for today’s episode. Next time we will examine whether the portfolio that worked for the past decade is the right one for the next ten. So, stay tuned. Join us for that conversation and all of our future episodes.
Christine Kashkari: If you enjoyed this episode and found it helpful, subscribe and share.
*Source for time stamp 8:00 – 8:12: Dickson, Joel, Marcos Dinerstein, Aaron Goodman, Fiona Greig, Kelly Hahn, Min Kim, Zachary Rayfield, and Nicky Zhang, “From Retirement Savings to a Retirement Paycheck,” Vanguard, 2026. $25,000 figure calculated from Vanguard Financial Advice Model simulations, using life expectancy assumptions from Society of Actuaries mortality tables, and steady state capital market and inflation assumptions from 10,000 Vanguard Capital Markets Model paths as of February 26, 2026.
Notes:
All annuities are subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest. Investments in bond portfolios are subject to interest rate, credit, and inflation risk. Product guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.
When taking withdrawals from an IRA or tax-deferred plan before age 59-1/2, you may have to pay ordinary income tax plus a 10% federal penalty tax.
Withdrawals from a Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA are generally tax free if you are over age 59-1/2 and have held the account for at least five years. If you take a withdrawal from your Roth account before age 59-1/2 and less than five years, a portion of the withdrawal may be subject to ordinary income tax or a 10% federal penalty, or both. (A separate five-year period applies to each conversion and begins on the first day of the year in which the contribution is made.)
Neither Vanguard nor its financial advisors provide tax and/or legal advice. This information is general and educational in nature and should not be considered tax and/or legal advice. Any tax-related information discussed herein is based on tax laws, regulations, judicial opinions and other guidance that are complex and subject to change. Additional tax rules not discussed herein may also be applicable to your situation. Vanguard makes no warranties with regard to such information or the results obtained by its use, and disclaims any liability arising out your use of, or any tax positions taken in reliance on, such information. We recommend you consult a tax and/or legal advisor about your individual situation.
This content was created by Custom Content from WSJ, a unit of The Wall Street Journal Advertising Department.
In this episode of Better Vantage, Kelly Hahn, Vanguard’s head of retirement research, and Garrett Harbron, Vanguard's head of advised wealth management strategies, reveal that only 1 in 10 Americans consistently withdraw from their retirement accounts, while about 40% wait until required minimum distributions force them to tap their wealth.
This reluctance to spend stems from anxiety about health care costs and longevity, but it often leads to unnecessary tax burdens and diminished quality of life. By waiting to tap retirement wealth until required minimum distributions begin at age 73 or 75, retirees may pay significantly more in aggregate lifetime taxes than if they had drawn down funds strategically in their early retirement years.1
Hahn and Harbron argue that creating a spending plan can act as a strong incentive to spend in retirement and minimize taxes. The plan should account for both essential expenses and discretionary goals, with dedicated reserves for health care uncertainties that one in two Americans will eventually face.
The path forward requires three essential steps: consolidate accounts for a holistic view, understand your Social Security timeline, and define the retirement lifestyle you want to afford. The goal is not simply preserving wealth but converting it into the experiences and security that make retirement meaningful.
Related links
Source:
1 Dickson, Joel, Marcos Dinerstein, Aaron Goodman, Fiona Greig, Kelly Hahn, Min Kim, Zachary Rayfield, and Nicky Zhang, “From Retirement Savings to a Retirement Paycheck,” Vanguard, 2026. $25,000 figure calculated from Vanguard Financial Advice Model simulations, using life expectancy assumptions from Society of Actuaries mortality tables, and steady state capital market and inflation assumptions from 10,000 Vanguard Capital Markets Model paths as of February 26, 2026.
Notes:
All investing is subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest. Diversification does not ensure a profit or protect against a loss.
All annuities are subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest. Investments in bond portfolios are subject to interest rate, credit, and inflation risk. Product guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company.
When taking withdrawals from an IRA or tax-deferred plan before age 59-1/2, you may have to pay ordinary income tax plus a 10% federal penalty tax.
Withdrawals from a Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA are generally tax free if you are over age 59-1/2 and have held the account for at least five years. If you take a withdrawal from your Roth account before age 59-1/2 and less than five years, a portion of the withdrawal may be subject to ordinary income tax or a 10% federal penalty, or both. (A separate five-year period applies to each conversion and begins on the first day of the year in which the contribution is made.)
Neither Vanguard nor its financial advisors provide tax and/or legal advice. This information is general and educational in nature and should not be considered tax and/or legal advice. Any tax-related information discussed herein is based on tax laws, regulations, judicial opinions and other guidance that are complex and subject to change. Additional tax rules not discussed herein may also be applicable to your situation. Vanguard makes no warranties with regard to such information or the results obtained by its use, and disclaims any liability arising out your use of, or any tax positions taken in reliance on, such information. We recommend you consult a tax and/or legal advisor about your individual situation.
This content was created by Custom Content from WSJ, a unit of The Wall Street Journal Advertising Department.